Who Is RIGHT pdf download

Who Is Right  – According to the Qur’an and Sunnah -Ibn Baaz, Ibn Uthaymeen or Albani? 

This is a translation of portions of a book called 

Al-Eejaaz Fi Ba’di Makhtalafa Fihi Al-Albaniyyu Wabnu Uthaymeen Wabn Baaz Rahimahom Allahu Ta’aala 

by Dr. Saeed bin Abdillah Al-Bareek Translated from Arabic by  Dr. S. Kose 

الايجاز في بعض ما اختلف فيه الالباني وابن عثيمين وابن لازم

Who Is Right

Some people who oppose the four Madhabs, also known as Salafis, would have us believe that the differences between the madhabs would not exist had the madhabs all followed the Qur’an and Sunnah.

 In this is an insinuation that the madhabs do not necessarily follow authentic hadith

This is why when Salafis see a hadith in Bukhari, Muslim, or one of Shaykh Albani’s books which contradicts a practice in a madhab,

 they come to the conclusion that madhabs must be wrong because they left out the saheeh hadith and followed either the opinion (ra’y) of their Imam, legal analogy (qiyaas), or a weak narration. In order to demonstrate that this is nothing more than a fallacy, I present the translated responses to 139 questions which were put to the three most popular Salafi scholars: Al-Shaykh Ibn Baaz, Al-Shaykh Ibn Uthaymeen, and Al-Shaykh Al-Albaani.

I doubt that any Salafi would surmise that all three are following the Qur’an and Sunnah incorrectly. 

Nonetheless, they manage to reach contradicting conclusions. Here is an example: Question 45:

 Does one raise his index finger during the sitting between two prostrations? Answer: Ibn Baaz: 

The Sunnah is not to raise the index finger during the sitting between the two prostrations. 

Ibn Uthaymeen: Raising the index finger is Sunnah during the sitting between the two prostration just like in tashahhud. 

Albani: Raising the index finger in any sitting other than the tashahhud is innovation (bid’ah). We have three different answers for one question